Help! My music student sings out of tune! [FREE printable!]

A lady once told me that when she was a little girl in a school choir, her music teacher instructed her to just mouth the words and to not make a sound. As the children around her carried the tune, she remained silent.

That was yesterday’s solution to singing out of tune: just discourage the person from singing at all.

Singing is one of the best things about being human. It’s a joy to sing! And any which way we sing gives us joy:

  • Singing with the car radio
  • Singing the national anthem at a sports game
  • Singing in a choir or in church
  • Singing around a camp fire
  • Singing when we fall in love
  • Singing when we try to soothe a baby to sleep

In short, humans love to sing. To believe that someone sings out of tune because they’re born that way, that it can’t be helped and then prevent them from singing, is a travesty.

I can’t think of anything else in the world that universally gives a sense of shame or failure as singing out of tune. It’s almost the ultimate sign you can’t belong.

When a music teacher notices that a student is singing out of tune, can it be helped?

Yes!

Let me make a bold claim. The game I’m offering in this blog post has had a 100% success rate with my students. Every student who has played this game with me has learned to sing in tune.

Yes, it is possible for someone who sings out of tune to learn how to sing in tune. The younger, the better.

The catch? You can’t skim this blog post. Don’t skip over parts and assume you’ve got it based on headings and a sentence or two.

To enjoy this success yourself, read every word. It will be worth your time.

1. Never say this

A red stop sign mounted on a pole against a textured gray wall.

Children who feel under threat cannot learn effectively. Their brain will shut down, as fear prevents learning.

If a child is asked to sing but already feels insecure or self-conscious about their singing abilities, they won’t. Any hint of criticism or assessment from the teacher will only shut them down and make them unwilling to try.

To be clear, a teacher should never say, “You sing out of tune.” Or any variation on that statement.

The first task of the teacher is therefore to lower the threat, to make the child feel comfortable and willing to try.

This is accomplished by introducing a game. Actually having fun and being silly is part of it. Being competitive is part of it.

The game requires you to act like a kid. If you’re not willing to act a little (as in, perform like an actor), it won’t be much fun, and the child will stand to make little gain.

The teacher losing intentionally sometimes is part of it (faking a loss but pretending the loss is real). Kids love outsmarting adults. It makes them willing to play the game, which requires them to sing.

Without knowing it, before long, they’ll be singing in tune. I’ll add, they won’t even realize that they’re going from singing out of tune to singing in tune. They won’t know the point of the game. To the piano student, it’s only a fun matching game.

2. Raise the challenge

A child climbing a colorful indoor climbing wall, reaching for various handholds.

After lowering the threat, the second precept of a good teaching strategy is to raise the challenge. Children love a good challenge. Through challenge they stretch their abilities, improve, get better and grow. A challenge turns on the light and fully engages them.

A challenge is anything that cannot be accomplished on the first try. A challenge requires sustained effort, input, deeper thought and problem-solving.

If a child doesn’t first try and fail, then strive, then succeed, they won’t learn anything. These three steps are essential to learning. Therefore, failure isn’t something to fear, it’s something to welcome because it means you’re on the path.

The Pitch Match Game requires a back-and-forth between the student and the teacher. And it is a challenge for both.

To someone who cannot sing in tune, matching a pitch with their voice is a challenge. But if the teacher were also expected to do the same, it wouldn’t be much of a competition.

So rather than expecting the same skill from both players, the teacher is expected to up their game with a bigger challenge.

In the first half of the game, the student will witness their teacher trying hard and putting in effort. The part the teacher has to play is actually very tricky. Let’s call it a “handicap”, like in a round of golf between unevenly matched players.

And, like golf, in this game you want a low score. A score of “1” means that you got the match on the first try, with the best possible result. In the box you’ll write the number of tries it took the teacher and student to match the pitch. The one with the lowest score wins that round.

I explain the game in more detail in the next section.

Logo of MaxMusic Piano eSheet Club featuring a cat sitting on a stack of sheet music.

Big Value, small price. Get $70 off the regular price of 12 new eSheets. Learn more!

3. The Pitch Match game

A smiling woman and a young boy sitting at a piano during a music lesson, with a decorated Christmas tree in the background.

Game step 1. First, the student sings a note. It can be any note.

The teacher then tries to play the matching key on the piano keyboard. Unless you have perfect pitch, this is a challenge. If you do have perfect pitch, you are going to have to fake some failures. Otherwise the game will be no fun, the student will lose interest in playing, and they won’t learn how to sing in tune.

But there’s a deeper reason for asking the student to sing first. In order to get someone to sing in tune, first you need to understand their comfortable vocal range. This first sung pitch from the student gives you that starting point.

Here’s why any other approach will fail. If your student had a naturally high voice, but you tried to get them to sing mid-range, it wouldn’t work. If your student’s voice were more in the mid-range but you tried to teach them to match a tone in the higher register, it wouldn’t work, either. It only makes sense to follow the student’s lead on their own singing range. I guess this is why some kids do sing out of tune. In a music class, the teacher starts on a higher note than the child is comfortable singing, so the student drones along on lower pitches, where they are more comfortable singing. What is true is that most of those who sing out of tune will sing below the pitch, not above it. To me, this signals that they should learn to sing on lower pitches to begin with.

The other reason the student sings and the teacher matches first is so the student can watch the teacher trying to match a pitch, which is difficult. After they witness effort and having fun, they’ll be willing to put in effort, too (and it will feel like fun).

Game step 2. Next, the teacher chooses a piano key near the student’s first pitch and plays it. You’ll choose this pitch because it is within the child’s comfortable singing range, which increases their chances of matching it.

Some kids will be able to match every pitch with confidence. For these kids, the game will be short-lived in lessons because it’ll offer no challenge to them. Usually things with more challenge are more fun. Easy things are a bit boring. So, for these kids the game will simply drop off the radar.

For other kids, it will be hit-and-miss. These kids will have the most fun, because they’ll love the competition and the challenge.

Still other children may never have sung before, and they may not know how to connect their voices to their breath supply and support a sustained sound. For these kids, the game can evolve a little into you challenging them to producing a clearer, more stable sound.

I highly recommend that you watch the following videos. You will see the Pitch Match Game in action and will learn some tricks on how to help when your students need to work harder to match the pitch. Notice that each video is only one to three minutes long. This doesn’t take a lot of lesson time, but over several lessons, it is very effective.

Just think about that. In one to three minutes each week, you can help a human find their voice.

4. Girl student

September 24th – This is our second time playing. One of us needs two tries and the other gets it first try! The competition is fierce!

October 1st – “Let’s play the Pitch Match game!” “YAY!” With some wobbly attempts, we work on a bit of breath support to make the sound clearer. The overall score is a surprise and we are baited into the next challenge!

October 8th – History repeats itself in a very strange turn of events. One competitor pulls ahead by one point.

October 15th – I challenge the student to sing in a different range. Then, she finds it tricky to match the pitch this time, so here’s a creative strategy for giving a little extra help. And it works!

Notice by the end of the game above that I offered to continue playing it. I didn’t say, “You’re still missing the match sometimes, so let’s keep going on this.” I simply stated that I thought we could have more fun if we kept playing it.

This ‘to be continued’ approach will help the child eventually match every time, and learn to sing in tune.

5. Boy student

September 2025 – Here’s this student’s first time playing Pitch Match. He wanted special help from his mom, and here’s how we included her for extra support. This built his confidence enough to even try. Note: Part of this video is sound only, but it’s definitely worth listening to.

October 4th – The student is still holding back a little, but there’s a quicker response this time. His mom is a great sport. Without her we might not be able to play this game, so these videos give a hint on how to help hesitant singers.

October 7th – On a roll, I bring out my pirate voice in this one. Notice what we celebrate and what we choose to let go for another lesson.

December 9th – This student usually hums with a lifted tongue, which constricts the sound. So, here’s how I get him to sing with an open mouth and better air support. This is building confidence beyond just matching the pitch to learning how to sing.

6. This FREE printable makes it easy!

I invented this game for my students to help them learn to sing with dignity. It’s challenging and fun!

Pitch Match

You have the advantage of drawing upon the decades of my teaching experience, to use this with your own students.

It’s easier with the FREE printable!

7. A bonus bit of silly humming

The free printable that goes with this blog post has a bonus sound experiment at the bottom, encouraging children to try it themselves.

When I was a child, I used to ride along on our wheeled vacuum cleaner while my mother vacuumed our house. And our vacuum cleaner had a very distinctive tone (I believe it was D4 on the piano).

A vintage Electrolux vacuum cleaner in a retro teal and silver design, featuring a handle and wheels for mobility.
The closest image I can find to a vacuum cleaner on wheels that I rode around while Mom vaccumed.

I would experiment with my voice, humming along but not always in tune with the vacuum. I’d begin below the pitch, then scoop my voice up very slowly, feeling the interactions between the pitch of my own voice and the pitch of the vacuum cleaner. As I got closer to the vacuum’s tone, sitting just microtones below it, I could feel the two pitches fighting each other. In organ tuning, this is called a “beat”, when two pitches go wah-wah-wah against each other. Then, when my voice finally matched that of the vacuum’s tone, the two would melt together in a silky smooth phase that seemed lighter than air. What a sensation! Then, I’d do it all over again. I’m not even sure my mother was aware that I was experimenting with the science of sound waves in my own little child-like way.

Nowadays I have a central vac, so it’s not possible to hear the motor or hum along while we run the vacuum. Other families may be in a similar situation. So, I thought I’d include some audio recordings of vacuum cleaners here from YouTube. Can your student find the pitch and hum along?

These sound samples aren’t very long, so maybe the student can play them several times and hum along — below, above and matching the pitch to listen to all the ways matched and mismatched pitches interact.


Singing can be a human’s greatest glory or hidden shame.

If a person knows how to sing in tune, they can confidently belt out the national anthem in a group, join a good choir and sing along to music at the piano.

If a person sings out of tune, they’ll forever hide it from others. They will be left out of one of the most bonding experiences humans can have: singing together.

Piano students who sing in tune stand to do better on their ear training, and better in music, period. They can internalize their understanding of music and phrasing in a more personal way. Singing in tune offers many benefits, artistically, intellectually and socially.

What are you waiting for?

Get started with the FREE printable!


Don’t miss a post!

Follow my blog (click here)! Get instant notifications of my posts in your inbox!

I appreciate shares, comments and likes. Happy teaching! <3

Rebekah Maxner
Rebekah Maxner, composer, blogger, piano teacher. Follow my blog for great tips!

Video of the Week

Treasure Chest (Early Elementary, Beginner). A Spanish sound adventure that includes sing-along lyrics so young piano students can practice singing!

This rote pattern piece on white and black keys includes a teacher duet. The student’s fingers imagine gemstones and the teacher creates the effect of strumming a Spanish guitar. Student part encourages non-legato playing and helps develop healthy beginner technique and listening for beautiful tone. The student pattern repeats up the piano and includes hand-to-hand octaves. From the print and eBook First Impressions, or check out the Treasure Chest eSheet!

Listen to Treasure Chest! My girl student from above sings along in tune!
First Impressions

Curious about First Impressions?

Impressionist rote music for beginners, with teacher duets! Find out more!

Read More

What every piano teacher needs to know about Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD)

Does a piano teacher have a right to talk to a child’s parents about how they learn?

Is this a tabu subject? Is this a private subject that a piano teacher has no right to discuss with parents? Do we risk upsetting them?

The truth is that neurodiverse people are often so intelligent that teachers (and parents) miss the fact that they’re struggling in some ways. After all, aren’t neurodiverse people somehow lacking? Wouldn’t it be more obvious?

Actually, no.

Children with ADHD can have exceptional intelligence, which means that when they struggle to organize their things or organize their practice time, it seems they’re just being lazy. It seems they’re full of potential but letting themselves down by not trying hard enough to meet it.

A piano teacher’s frustration builds over missed assignments, forgotten practice, slow progress and unfinished pieces. And when this pattern builds with a particularly talented student, the teacher can be at wits end. It may seem impossible to think of strategies that will help this student to try harder, or remember something, or follow through.

Once a teacher educates themselves on what neurodiversity looks like (and in this blog post we’re focusing on Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, or ADHD), it will become easier to know how to help these special kids.

I feel that it’s important to avoid negative language surrounding neurodiversity and ADHD. Steer clear of articles and videos that cast ADHD people as deficient (unfortunately, these do exist). I’ve combed through YouTube to find videos that will help you learn from people who are living and thriving with ADHD and who celebrate their differences.

Each of the following videos is created by an expert. Dr. Thomas E. Brown offers an excellent overview from a psychologist’s point of view on ADHD and how the ADHD brain is different. Following are three videos from Jessica McCabe, who has some of the best ADHD content on YouTube right now. Her channel is called ‘How to ADHD’. The first is on potential, then her own personal journey of diagnosis, failure and success. She also covers how people try to help those with ADHD in ways that don’t actually help. Finally, I’ve added a video by Dr. Tracey Marks on time management, something those with ADHD truly struggle with. You may wish to continue her series on YouTube.

There’s a wealth of understanding that can be gained from each video, and I hope that you will make time to watch each one through.

Now, let the videos speak for themselves.

1. A closer look into ADHD – Dr. Thomas E. Brown

ADD/ADHD What is Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder?

In the past, I didn’t think it was the piano teacher’s place to address neurodiversity in students. I thought classroom teachers would be better trained to pick up on it, and if a child had ADHD, it would already have been identified and the accommodations would already be in place.

However, classroom teachers and parents often only notice the hyperactive kind of ADHD in children. When a child can’t sit still or is constantly disruptive, or if they struggle to learn, these behaviours flag the child for diagnosis. These kids get help.

But there’s a whole other side to ADHD that teachers and parents routinely miss. It’s the children who have overactive imaginations, who are lost in their vibrant pretend worlds–who have more interesting things going on in their heads than are happening in the real world around them, who cannot pay attention–who don’t get diagnosed, and therefore don’t get help.

This is ADHD (Inattentive presentation). These quiet, intelligent, artistic children can end up in piano lessons.

2. You Have So Much Potential – How to HDHD

Quite often ADHD looks very different in girls than it does in boys. Whereas boys can be hyper and impulsive, girls can be dreamy and forgetful. This may be why boys are diagnosed more often than girls, and get more help earlier in their lives than girls.

Statistically, there are more girls in piano lessons, and also more female piano teachers. It is therefore possible that there’s a larger population of individuals with undiagnosed ADHD in the piano lesson world than in the general public.

3. Failing at Normal: An ADHD Success Story – Jessica McCabe

Another group that falls through the cracks is highly sensitive and artistic boys. Their ADHD is missed because many people believe incorrect stereotypes of what ADHD is.

Therefore, these quiet kids don’t get equal access to help. And they may go through life having to work harder than others, going through much steeper personal odds simply to cover the basics. Fighting their own inertia becomes exhausting, and it doesn’t have to be this way.

Because there may be a higher rate of ADHD in piano lessons, it’s very important for us piano teachers to educate ourselves on what it is. What are the currently known characteristics of ADHD? How do those with ADHD struggle? Are there ways for us to identify a student and develop helpful accommodations?

One thing is sure, when I looked further into ASD and ADHD, I became a much kinder teacher. The frustration I used to feel with common student ‘failures’ is now nearing zero.

4. 5 Ways People Try to Help Someone with ADHD

To be clear, it is not the place of any piano teacher to suggest a diagnosis to a parent, and certainly not to a child. This post isn’t about attempting to diagnose your piano students. Its purpose is simply to encourage you to become aware of the latest thinking on ADHD so that you might create your own in-house accommodations quietly and unobtrusively with children who might display some (or many) of the characteristics.

In essence, understanding ADHD might help you become a better piano teacher for a special segment of your student population.

5. How to Help Your Piano Students who are Not Reaching Their Full Potential

In November, 2023, Amy Chaplin invited me (Rebekah Maxner) to be a guest speaker on her Piano Pantry Podcast. My focus is on helping you understand students who may not be reaching their full potential. Some of these kids may be neurodiverse. I offer scenarios that are common frustrations to piano teachers with students who forget assignments or just can’t seem to get organized, followed by possible solutions. Check out Piano Pantry Podcast’s Episode 93 here.

6. A piano teacher can be a key player in getting kids help

As was said above, it isn’t the piano teacher’s job to diagnose or suggest a diagnosis for their piano students. Simply put, we aren’t qualified.

However, given the unique position that piano teachers hold, observing hundreds of children over the years and observing any single child over an expanse of time, you may begin to see patterns of behaviour in students in general, and patterns in a child in particular. Piano teachers may even catch traits that others miss.

In order to get children the help they need and deserve, there is a way to discreetly ask if parents are willing to hear from you about the way their child learns.

First, it might be best to ask parents in a general way, perhaps in a questionnaire that all parents fill out. This may remove any awkwardness later on if you notice characteristics in their child and are unsure how to open the conversation.

A questionnaire broaches the subject in a hypothetical way and asks for the parents’ permission for you to contact them should you notice anything about the way their child learns.

Excerpt from Parent Questionnaire.

When a parent answers, “Yes,” they invite your input. When approaching the parent, you wouldn’t mention ASD or ADHD by name, but simply ask if they’ve noticed this or that about their child, and ask if they’ve ever considered having their child assessed. A parent wants the very best for their child and your sensitivity and observation might make a difference to them. In my own experience as a piano teacher, I’ve carefully approached several parents in this way and it has gone well. After the initial conversation, I then let them move forward with professionals who are qualified in assessment.

Please visit my Printables section for a FREE printable called Questionnaire for New Piano Parents. You may download a Word doc that you can edit, or a PDF.

It isn’t about giving a kid a label, it’s about helping them become understood and getting them the help they need.

7. Bonus: Need help with time management and organization?

Dr. Tracey Marks has a wonderful YouTube series on time management. Begin here.

>> Check out this sister post on Autism (ASD)

More than a classroom teacher, more than a sports coach and sometimes even more than a parent, a piano teacher holds a unique position in a child’s life. We observe the children in our studios in a very focused learning environment once a week. This blog post explores Autism (ASD) as a first step to help piano teachers know how to respond to neurodiversity in the piano studio environment. Link >> What every piano teacher needs to know about Autism (ASD)


Don’t miss a post!

Follow my blog (click here)! Get instant notifications of my posts in your inbox!

I appreciate shares, comments and likes. Happy teaching! ❤

Rebekah Maxner, composer, blogger, piano teacher. Follow my blog for great tips!

Video of the Week

Rock 3 (Early Intermediate, Level 3). Rock ‘n Roll style! Explores the E Major key signature in black and white key patterns that are easy to learn by rote, plus the eighth rest. Rock 3 is a pun on ‘rock’ music, a play on words of Rach 3 (the piano concerto), and the fact that we live on the third planet from the sun, (remember title of the TV series?). Rock 3 is available in the print and eBook Rock That Train, and as a studio-licensed eSheet!

Listen to Rock 3 on YouTube!

Read More

What every piano teacher needs to know about Autism (ASD)

In a child’s life, a piano teacher holds a unique position.

More than a classroom teacher, more than a sports coach and sometimes even more than a parent, a piano teacher observes a child in a very focused learning environment once a week. This mentor-trainee relationship may continue for years. This gives the piano student the advantage of being overseen by a caring adult who has the opportunity to become aware of his or her strengths and struggles in a long term and personal way.

Neurodiversity is a key buzzword in today’s educational circles, with teachers and students embracing the topic both as educators and learners.

As information about Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) continues to expand in scope and understanding, it is imperative for piano teachers to strive to stay informed.

If a piano teacher were to go forward based on what was known or assumed about autism twenty (or even ten) years ago, it would be unfortunate.

I feel that it’s important to avoid negative language surrounding neurodiversity and ASD. Steer clear of articles and videos that cast Autistic people as deficient (unfortunately, these do exist). I’ve combed through YouTube to find videos that will help you learn from people who are living and thriving with ASD and who celebrate their differences.

Each of the following videos is created by an expert. Tashi Baiguerra and Emmy Peach cover ASD from the personal experience of women with autism. Professor Tony Atwood is a psychologist who has been working with people with ASD for more than 40 years, and his own son has autism. Kati Morton is a therapist and takes time to explain autism and the brain and specific characteristics to watch for. She also gives some hints on how teachers might respond.

There’s a wealth of understanding that can be gained from each video, and I hope that you will make time to watch each one through.

Now, let the videos speak for themselves.

1. My brain isn’t broken – Tashi Baiguerra

In the past I believed classroom teachers would have better training in recognizing neurodiversity in children and would have the professional duty to get them help, make accommodations and possibly even initiate the pathway to diagnosis.

However, I now feel that classroom teachers may be at a disadvantage because they are managing so many difficult dynamics in the classroom. Classroom teachers usually only interact with a child for one year. They may not have time to properly observe their quieter students. In a classroom, it’s the noisy birds in the nest who get the attention, and therefore, the help.

2. Could it be ASPERGERS? – Prof. Tony Attwood

Quieter students, perhaps the ones who end up in piano lessons, may be better at masking their ASD. They become good at flying under the radar. That’s why girls and women often don’t get tested or diagnosed until they are in their late teens, or even as late as mid-life (and may actually never get diagnosed).

Another group that falls through the cracks is highly intelligent and perfectionistic boys. Their autism is missed because many people believe incorrect stereotypes of what autism is and their perfectionism becomes a shield or defence that hides their struggles.

Therefore, these quiet girls and perfectionistic boys don’t get equal access to help. And they may go through life feeling very misunderstood.

3. Unmasking the Stigma Behind Autism in Females – Emmy Peach

To be clear, it is not the place of any piano teacher to suggest a diagnosis to a parent, and certainly not to a child. This post isn’t about attempting to diagnose your piano students. Its purpose is simply to encourage you to become aware of the latest thinking on ASD so that you might create your own in-house accommodations quietly and unobtrusively with children who might display some (or many) of the characteristics.

In essence, understanding ASD might help you become a better piano teacher for a special segment of your student population.

4. What is High Functioning Autism? Kati Morton

The main reason you will benefit from this blog exploratory on autism is that it will help you to recognize possible characteristics of ASD in your students. You’ll begin to understand how to organize your studio, your lesson plans and how to reach and teach these children. Some of these children may be diagnosed and others may not. Regardless, you’ll be able to develop appropriate and effective responses.

Another spinoff benefit of this exploratory may be to better understand yourself. Because it was believed for so long that Autism mainly presented in boys, girls have slipped through the cracks.

The piano teaching profession is populated predominantly by female teachers and I suspect that for some of my readers, these videos may turn on a light of self-discovery in which you may finally begin to understand yourself. There can be mixed feelings when this happens, so if you need support, don’t brave it alone. Psychologists and therapists are wonderful helpers and may do wonders for you.

5. Motivating students with ASD and ADHD – Abigail Profitt

On February 28th, 2023, Amy Chaplin’s Piano Pantry Podcast featured a guest episode by Abigail Profitt. Abigail focused on motivating piano students with diagnosed ASD and ADHD. As a piano teacher, she specializes in teaching neurodiverse children. Her tips are practical, actionable and brilliant. I hope you will take a listen to this episode, which is less than 15 minutes long. Check out Piano Pantry Podcast’s Episode 58 here.

6. A piano teacher can be a key player in getting kids help

As was said above, it isn’t the piano teacher’s job to diagnose or suggest a diagnosis for their piano students. Simply put, we aren’t qualified.

However, given the unique position that piano teachers hold, observing hundreds of children over the years and observing any single child over an expanse of time, you may begin to see patterns of behaviour in students in general, and patterns in a child in particular. Piano teachers may even catch traits that others miss.

In order to get children the help they need and deserve, there is a way to discreetly ask if parents are willing to hear from you about the way their child learns.

First, it might be best to ask parents in a general way, perhaps in a questionnaire that all parents fill out. This may remove any awkwardness later on if you notice characteristics in their child and are unsure how to open the conversation.

A questionnaire broaches the subject in a hypothetical way and asks for the parents’ permission for you to contact them should you notice anything about the way their child learns.

Excerpt from Parent Questionnaire.

When a parent answers, “Yes,” they invite your input. When approaching the parent, you wouldn’t mention ASD or ADHD by name, but simply ask if they’ve noticed this or that about their child, and ask if they’ve ever considered having their child assessed. A parent wants the very best for their child and your sensitivity and observation might make a difference to them. In my own experience as a piano teacher, I’ve carefully approached several parents in this way and it has gone well. After the initial conversation, I then let them move forward with professionals who are qualified in assessment.

Please visit my Printables section for a FREE printable called Questionnaire for New Piano Parents. You may download a Word doc that you can edit, or a PDF.

7. Bonus – Neurodiversity hiding in plain view

Glenn Gould is the poster child of brilliance in neurodiversity.

To emphasize that we have nothing to fear in recognizing neurodiversity in our teachers, performers, composers, students, or in ourselves, consider how many of our revered artists are clearly neurodiverse. One only has to watch Glenn Gould in action to see that he’s completely immersed in a different world. His obsession with perfection, his hyperfocus, his awkwardness, the fact that he hummed while playing, all attest to his neurodiversity. Once you see it you can’t unsee it.

Neurodiversity isn’t something to fear, it’s something to understand and embrace. It’s an advantage when it comes to thinking outside the box, being a maverick, being brave and breaking new ground. To make the best of neurodiversity, learn everything you can about it.

>> Check out this sister post on Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD)

Children with ADHD can have exceptional intelligence, which means that when they struggle to organize their things or organize their practice time, it seems they’re just being lazy. It seems they’re full of potential but letting themselves down by not trying hard enough to meet it. Most people are aware of the hyperactive kind of ADHD but there’s another kind–characteristic of the inattentive, dreamy, absentminded individual. To be an effective teacher, find out what’s currently known about ADHD. Link >> What every piano teacher needs to know about Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder.


Don’t miss a post!

Follow my blog (click here)! Get instant notifications of my posts in your inbox!

I appreciate shares, comments and likes. Happy teaching! ❤

Rebekah Maxner, composer, blogger, piano teacher. Follow my blog for great tips!

Video of the Week

Cold Snap! (Intermediate, Level 4) is a jazzy little number characterized by an infectious Cuban clave rhythm 1-2-3 / 1-2-3 / 1-2 with syncopations and the percussive effect of snapping fingers. The name of the piece is a pun. In cold climates like mine in Canada, there can be ‘cold snaps’ in the winter — periods of time during which the temperature plummets well below the average. Cold Snap! is available as a studio-licensed eSheet!

Listen to Cold Snap! on YouTube!

Read More

Returning piano student Questionnaire helps focus goals for new lesson year

It’s all about engagement.

The best way to keep your students interested, to draw them in, is to tap into their knowledge about themselves–to ask them pointed questions that will help you better understand them as young musicians.

I’ve tried various things in the past (writing “report card” responses, for example). But I’ve learned that asking the student to give me the report is the most effective way to create piano lessons that keep them hooked.

This year 100% of my students who returned last year are returning again.

I owe this in no small part to the fact that I gave them questionnaires to fill out at the beginning of last year’s lessons, to help me understand their likes (and dislikes) and in general, to find out what makes them ‘tick’ as developing musicians.

I highly recommend adding questionnaires to your piano lesson routine. Here’s the simple outline:

1. Short answers guide future choices

On the first page, ask students to give feedback that will help you to personalize their piano lesson experience–music styles they like (or don’t like), and their individual take on what they feel works and doesn’t work.

Below, I outline what I’m curious to learn about my students’ piano lesson experience and follow each question with a list of some of their responses.

I’m impressed with the amount of thought they put into their responses.

Favourite pieces so far (name as many as you can remember).

  • Rainbow (Maxner)
  • Beach session (Dow), Shades of Blue (Bober), Haunted Music Box (Maxner), Boogie Woogie Man (Maxner)
  • The Icing on the Cake (the song that has four pages)
  • Menuet (Petzold)
  • Polonaise (attr. Bach)
  • Für Elise (Beethoven, arranged), Taps
  • Morning (Grieg, arranged)

Some have chosen favourites based on style, which indicates that they’re motivated by the sound of the music. Others have chosen a piece that took the most effort and practicing, which indicates that they’re driven by challenge and the feeling of accomplishment. I’d imagine that it’s often a little of both. But understanding this helps you know how to interest them going forward.

Favourite styles of music.

  • Romantic
  • Pop, country, rock and roll!
  • Pop, funk, country, rock, blues
  • 12 bar blues
  • Fast music
  • Slow music
  • Classical music, minor music

Knowing this will help in the selection of new repertoire. While it’s good from a teacher’s standpoint to offer students a balanced slate of music from different stylistic periods, knowing their favourite style will help you be sure that you keep a piece in circulation that targets it to keep up interest.

Also, if a student is adverse to a particular kind of music, I feel that there’s no reason to belabour it. Let it go for now. That’s the luxury of teaching individual lessons. We get to customize their learning experience. Maybe sometime in the future they’ll grow and be open to explore beyond their present-day boundaries.

You’d like to do more of THIS in piano lessons.

  • Learning technical things
  • Rhythm cups, flash cards
  • Rhythm cups and the Pattern Play
  • Improvising
  • Rhythm cups and drums
  • Rhythm cups, 8 rainbow tubes (Boomwhackers)
  • Faster pieces

This is an excellent question to find out what each student loves about their piano lessons. Anything listed here can be programmed more into the lesson time.

Can you name any pieces you truly didn’t like learning or practising?

  • Most students answered “no”
  • Star Trooper

It’s important to find out what your student didn’t connect with. This kind of information will help you to steer clear of the dangerous zone of losing a student’s interest.

What in piano do you feel you do really well?

  • Dynamics, learning pieces on my own (YOYO)
  • Rhythm cups
  • Reading the music
  • Tempo
  • Practicing
  • Learning by ear

It’s not enough to know something. It’s better to know what you know. For this reason, I feel it means more for the student to be given the chance to identify what they do well, rather than me telling them as their teacher.

What in piano do you find extra tricky?

  • Learning multiple pieces at once
  • Dotted-quarter-eighth rhythms
  • Technical things, key signatures (the harder ones, less common)
  • Long pieces
  • Fitting a piece together
  • Playing between white and black keys quickly
  • Recitals

Rather than following up the question “what do you do well” with the reverse, “what don’t you do well,” I felt it sounded a little kinder to say “what do you find tricky”.

I remember as a student that I mixed up F and G notes written in every octave. I never had the opportunity to explain that to my teacher, so the stumbling point lasted long into my lesson experience, longer than it should have.

There may be little hidden stumbling points with some of our students that we are not aware of. They may be too ashamed to admit some things that they don’t understand. By giving them the chance to identify things that trick them, you are opening yourself up to finding ways to problem-solve with them, to collaborate to help them secure the concept as a learner.

Is there anything in piano that you dread doing?

  • No
  • Long pieces
  • Scales
  • Recitals
  • Improvising

Knowing what the student dreads can help you either de-emphasize those things in lessons or to find a way to help the child get more comfortable with them. Depending on their answer, you may wish to tap into their parents’ knowledge to help with a strategy.

What strategies help you have really good practise sessions?

  • No TV without practice
  • When I have a friend coming over later 🙂
  • When daddy helps
  • Remembering to do it
  • After school is best

It’s key to learn as much as possible about how your students practise at home. By asking this question, I hoped that each student would put their finger on what encourages success at home, to help them ‘buy in’ to making that strategy a habit.

What strategies help practicing go smoothly?

  • When daddy helps (me one hand, dad other hand)
  • Focusing
  • Keep repeating
  • Better when I am pumped up!
  • Candy

This follow-up question asked the student to dig deeper, to further contemplate practicing. It opens a potential conversation between teacher, student and parent to create a plan that will work.

2. Check boxes allow student to rate lesson experiences

The second page of my questionnaire allows each student to rate on a scale of five (1 being low and 5 being high), a number of specific activities and music styles we experience in piano lessons. Because these are unique to my piano studio and not easily transferrable to yours, I’ve listed them here as an example only. You could customize this for your own students.

N.B. The student can mark any one of these “n/a” if it’s not applicable.

  • Building rhythms with note cards.
  • Rhythm Cups (a resource from Wendy Stevens).
  • Improvising with Pattern Play (a resource from Forrest Kinney).
  • Scales, triads and arpeggios (technical work).
  • Composing original music.
  • Baroque music (Bach, Handel, etc.).
  • Classical music (Clementi, Beethoven, etc.).
  • Romantic music (Schumann, Mendelssohn, etc.)
  • 20th Century music (Bartok, Kabalevsky, etc.).
  • Popular music (anything popular goes).
  • Music by my piano teacher (Maxner) – be honest 😉

3. Year-to-year comparison

I plan to compile this questionnaire year-after-year and compare and contrast each single student’s responses over time. Have the student’s preferences remained the same? Have they grown? Have some things that used to trick them now become easier?

As I continue to grow as a teacher, I continue to search for ways to listen better to my students, to let them be a guiding force in how piano lessons play out.

With experience comes wisdom, and my current thoughts are telling me that I mustn’t forget what it’s like to be a child in piano lessons. To keep my head in that game, what better way is there than to ask them directly what they feel about their experiences?

Do you have any suggestions for other questions? Please leave a comment!


Don’t miss a post!

Follow my blog (click here)! Get instant notifications of my posts in your inbox!

I appreciate shares, comments and likes. Happy teaching! ❤

Rebekah Maxner, composer, blogger, piano teacher. Follow my blog for great tips!

Video of the Week

Autumn Afternoon (Early Advanced, Level 7). Autumn Afternoon is a slow jazz waltz that allows much room for the imagination. It gives opportunities for students to explore pacing of dynamics within the larger structure, and shaping RH phrases as well as the LH waltz pattern. Levels: US, Late Intermediate. AMEB, Level 6. ABRSM, Level 6. RCM, Level 7. Available as the studio-licensed Autumn Afternoon eSheet!

Listen to Autumn Afternoon on YouTube.

Read More

Need an alternative to sight reading? YOYO boosts staff reading (and students will actually do it)

How many of your piano students like to sight read?

The more important question is: how many of your students avoid sight reading?

If you score low on students who like it and high on students who avoid it, this blog post is for you!

The traditional reading approach is to teach students to be able to play music accurately at first sight–to sight read. Now, let’s toss that idea OUT the window. Phew! Watch it go! And…it’s gone.

Now that we’ve gotten rid of the traditional idea, let’s move on to a better one.

I prefer to teach my students to read music in a way that helps them to learn music more easily.

YOYO reading means “You’re On Your Own.” I wish I could take credit for the idea because it’s wonderful. I got it from a teacher on a Facebook group. After several years of success with it, I want to spread the idea around.

Before we get started

Watch this quick video of a student YOYO piece. She taught this to herself in a week.

‘If I Were a Rich Man’ from Fiddler on the Roof.

Wasn’t that great? For context the student above is a Late Elementary student, who regularly learns repertoire in RCM Level 1.

In my studio, that quality of student reading and on-your-own preparation is what I hear every week.

Student taught 8 measures, learns whole piece

Here’s another quick video of a student who was taught only eight measures of a piece. This was his very first piece in the 6/8 time signature. I wrote the stop sign into his music as a reminder to him and myself that we had covered only 8 measures together in the intro lesson, and that’s all I expected him to practice.

At his following lesson, he played the entire piece, having learned the rest on his own in just one week. Take a listen!

Back Street Blues by Rebekah Maxner, student finished learning it on his own.

Are your students this confident to learn music on their own?

Sure, as teachers we can hear the little spots that need polishing. BUT–this practicing demonstrates wonderful confidence with reading!

This isn’t just possible in my studio with my students! YOU can nurture this level of confidence in reading with your students, too!

Regularly including YOYO pieces in practice routines will build up reading skills over time for each individual student and overall in your entire studio!

1. Why sight reading doesn’t work for everyone

For some students, sight reading is very stressful.

The more stress a child feels, the worse they’ll do.

Sight reading comes with the expectation to strive to be perfect (or nearly perfect) on the very first reading. And to let mistakes go and to keep the steady beat going no matter what. So much is invested in this that it can create a crushing level of anxiety.

Some children feel so much pressure to be perfect “in one take” that a small mistake will completely undo them. In a sight reading situation, a breakdown in flow is equated with absolute failure.

Neurodiverse kids, kids who are highly distractible (little noises throw them off), kids who have differences in how their brains are wired or how they process incoming information, may all experience undue stress when expected to sight read.

Perfectionists may put so much pressure on themselves that it becomes all or nothing. There is no acceptable middle. For many, it feels easier to choose “nothing,” so they avoid reading altogether.

Instead of putting the focus on perfection the first time, put the focus on bouncebackability. Sticking with it, even with little setbacks. Persevering.

Did you make a mistake that stopped you in your tracks? Take another go at it. Keep trying. YOYO eases the pressure from the “now” and spreads the process over a longer timeframe.

2. The students who need sight reading…don’t

Every piano teacher knows the struggle to get certain students to read music. And it seems as though the very students who would benefit the most, don’t do it.

For students who struggle to read music, sight reading can be like wading knee-deep in thick mud. The music comes slowly, maybe in fits and starts or all-out stops. It just doesn’t sound good. That’s why students avoid it. As painful as it is for you to watch and listen to it unfold, it’s even more painful for the student.

If your overall goal is to help students to become better at reading music, then consider using an approach that allows them to read 1) without your scrutiny, 2) at their own pace, and 3) on their own time.

Your first task is to encourage every student to try–to get them to invest in the effort of reading to play music. In short, this delicate task is to turn students who don’t into students who DO.

3. Find reading that students will actually do

The general rule with sight reading is to read two levels down from the level of your repertoire. So, a Level 5 student would sight read Level 3 music.

Now let’s toss that idea out the window, too.

A better idea is to choose a comfortable level of music for your student. Setting an arbitrary level that students should be able to sight read just leads to frustration with some kids. Instead, think deeply about this student’s real-life capabilities, and go from there.

For my Elementary to Intermediate level students, I’ve had great success with the Faber supplementary library. We use the Piano Adventures Repertoire and Popular Repertoire books for YOYO reading. We don’t use this series in regular piano lessons, so the music is fresh and new for them.

The Faber library levelling is so consistent and the pieces so appealing that it motivates today’s kids to learn the music on their own. Even if your students have already learned from the method, you may still have success with titles they haven’t before played (below their current level).

Another option could be to consult your library of studio-licensed music and print off sheets you know they’ll enjoy learning.

Or, if your student has a collection of past repertoire books that have only been partially learned, look through for lost nuggets that might revive use of that book.

4. Reading with a purpose to learn

Even the name of this reading activity sounds fun: YOYO. When something sounds fun to do, it’ll catch your student’s attention.

When you have a child’s attention and they think something will be fun, they’ll invest effort. And what follows effort? True learning.

The saying goes, “First, you learn to read, then you read to learn.” But for some children, maybe the two are more intertwined. Maybe it takes reading to learn to learn how to read. That’s how YOYO works, anyway.

5. How to assign YOYO pieces

After I’ve chosen the book for the child, we go through it in the order that the pieces are printed. They’ll learn one piece at a time (one piece per week, ideally).

In the lesson I will play it for them, once. After all, I want them to be excited to play this music! They’ll be learning this piece unassisted. So, to invest in that effort, they first need to be sold on the sounds of the music.

When you think about it, how often does anyone play music that they’ve never, ever heard? Professional musicians may have this skill…but children? There’s nothing wrong (and everything right) with playing the music first.

I’ll talk about the context of a piece. If it’s a hit from Broadway, I’ll briefly mention that. I encourage them to listen to the original recording on YouTube at home. If it’s an arrangement, I’ll explain that the one they’re learning is based on the original but not exactly the same.

In the lesson, that’s it. They don’t try it for me. I don’t point out rhythms or notes or anything. In their dictation book I don’t write pointers. Just “YOYO” and the title.

They’re pushed out of the nest on this one with the belief that they’ll be able to find their wings and fly on their own.

6. How YOYO develops literacy

Fiddler on the Roof original poster.

YOYO reading develops literacy in two ways.

First, it develops a child’s reading literacy. What does it mean to read? It means to read the symbols and make the sounds at the same time (notice that same time isn’t the same thing as first sight).

Quite often as a child learns to read words in story books, they will re-read the same story many, many times. They memorize it. After it is memorized, their eyes still skim the words. The flow they achieve by knowing the words before they read them, helps them to learn to read. Reading fluency is developed through repetition. Through comfort. Through enjoying it. The familiarity with the text drives the desire to read.

The same flow is achieved with reading YOYO pieces. As the student reads and plays the piece through many times during the week, they get more and more familiar with it, get better at playing it, and develop flow playing it as they continue to read it. In this sense, this truly is the best way to teach a child how to read music.

Second, YOYO develops literacy–as in the knowledge of music literature. Many of the kids do listen to the originals on YouTube. It’s wonderful how they take this mature step of researching their music. The bonus value of YOYO is that students are experiencing music from our collective culture that they may never have heard before–like tunes from Fiddler on the Roof. This music is worth knowing!

7. Next or fix?

In the follow-up lesson, most of my students are excited to play their YOYO piece for me. They’re proud. They’ve worked hard. And they know that what they’ve done is special.

I’m proud of them! Wow! What a feeling as a teacher–you’ve taught this little person how to read music (incredible) and now they’ve been able (and willing) to use that skill to learn music on their own!

I’m blown away when they play their piece for me, and I let them know it! Maybe it’s my level of pride and how I gush about their accomplishment that spurs them on and on with this assignment. And I don’t fake it. I’m genuinely excited for them!

I’m a “glass half full” kind of teacher with YOYO assignments. We don’t tend to fix. As an afterthought I’ll point out a little problem and say, “If you want to keep playing this piece, try this….” — but then — it’s done! It’s their choice whether they keep playing it or fix the problem.

The real exercise was to see how much they could learn on their own. I take mental notes of little challenges and then we simply move on to the next piece.

The key to becoming a better reader is to enjoy reading! And to go through a volume of reading material!

8. Are they truly reading with YOYO?

It’s been said that to become a lifelong musician, one must learn how to read music well. We can throw that idea out the window with all of the other bad ideas mentioned above. There are countless musicians who make more cash than I do who can’t read a note.

But imagine encouraging kids who would typically struggle to read to become comfortable at it. That’s what YOYO reading does.

I’m amazed when I see my students playing their YOYO assignments. I watch their overall approach and watch their eyes. They are tracking the sheet music with their eyes as they play–truly reading and playing. With flow.

The answer is YES–this approach does get kids to learn how to read.

YOYO encourages curiosity, self-sufficiency and helps students fly on their own. 

After I’d been doing this for a while, one by one my students brought pieces to their lessons that they’d taught themselves without me even asking them to.

It was truly a magical moment for me as a teacher, and it happened across several families. What I was instilling in my students wasn’t an obsession with being perfect on one reading, but reading with a purpose to learn.

It’s the best thing I’ve ever done on the reading front.

You are encouraged to give this approach a try with your students! Please let me know how it goes! I’d love to hear in the comments!


Don’t miss a post!

Follow my blog (click here)! Get instant notifications of my posts in your inbox!

I appreciate shares, comments and likes. Happy teaching! ❤

Rebekah Maxner, composer, blogger, piano teacher. Follow my blog for great tips!

Video of the Week

Kaleidoscope Dream (Late Elementary, Level 1). Here’s a piece that reflects the beauty and mesmerizing slow cascade of colours in a kaleidoscope as you turn it towards the light! Explores rolling eighths and dotted-quarters in 6/8 meter and is ideal as an introduction to the time signature! Available as the studio-licensed Kaleidoscope Dream eSheet!

Listen to Kaleidoscope Dream on YouTube!
Listen to a sound clip of Spy Game!

Read More

Intervals: Sure-fire songs for memorizing by ear [ascending and descending]

When it comes to learning intervals by ear, you want unforgettable tunes that will get stuck in your head! Let’s call them Ear Training Ear Worms!

I’ve attempted to curate the most memorable tunes for each interval, as well as the best music videos.

Sometimes it’s tempting to jump on current songs because they’re popular with our students right now. This is okay, but in two years those tunes will be the least desirable to the next generation of students because of pop music’s rapid turnover. You’ll be searching endlessly for new songs.

Instead, I’ve here opted to include standards that have stood the test of time. True, maybe students haven’t heard them all before. Regardless, these tunes are quick to learn as Ear Training Ear Worms (mnemonic devices) and are valuable to know because they belong to our vast shared musical culture and canon. It’s simply edifying to know this cross-section of music!


You’re reading the companion post to Ear training Interval Dash, off-the-bench teaching strategy [Printables]! This off-the-bench resource teaches intervals by ear and visualizes them spatially without using notation. When all laid out, the interval cards look like a hop-scotch! It’s highly effective in helping students to gain a sound perspective and to learn to identify intervals by ear with accuracy. Plus, it’s fun! …


All of the intervals are indexed below in order from smallest to biggest. This is for ease of finding them, rather than a suggested order of learning them. Some examples have the main interval alternate up and down and could be used for both!

Perfect Unison — Happy Birthday

Listen to the traditional Happy Birthday on YouTube!

Minor 2nd Ascending — Jaws Theme

Listen to John Williams’s Jaws Theme on YouTube! (Minor 2nd at 0:27)

Minor 2nd Descending — Für Elise

Listen to Ludwig van Beethoven’s Für Elise on YouTube! (Minor 2nd at 0:20)

Major 2nd Ascending — Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer

Listen to Johnny Marks’s Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer on YouTube (Major 2nd at 0:23).

Major 2nd Descending — Mary Had a Little Lamb

Listen to the traditional Mary Had a Little Lamb on YouTube!

Minor 3rd Ascending — Oh Where, Oh Where has My Little Dog Gone?

Minor 3rd Descending — This Old Man

Listen to the traditional This Old Man on YouTube!

Major 3rd Ascending — Oh When the Saints go Marching In

Listen to the traditional Oh When the Saints go Marching In on YouTube!

Major 3rd Descending — Shoo! Fly, Don’t Bother Me!

Listen to the traditional Shoo! Fly, Don’t Bother Me! on YouTube!

Perfect 4th Ascending — Here Comes the Bride

Listen to Richard Wagner’s Bridal Chorus from Lohengrin on YouTube!

Perfect 4th Descending — I’ve Been Working on the Railroad

Listen to the traditional song I’ve Been Working on the Railroad on YouTube!

Tritone Ascending — The Simpsons Theme

Listen to Danny Elfman’s The Simpsons end credits on YouTube!

Tritone Descending — Danse Macabre

Listen to Camille Saint-Saëns’s Danse Macabre on YouTube! (Tritone at 0:24)

Perfect 5th Ascending — Star Wars Theme

Listen to John Williams’s Star Wars theme on YouTube! (Perfect 5th at 0:08)

Perfect 5th Descending — The Flintstones Theme

Minor 6th Ascending — The Entertainer

Listen to Scott Joplin’s The Entertainer on YouTube! (Minor 6th at 0:09)

Minor 6th Descending — Love Story Theme

Listen to Francis Lai’s Love Story theme on YouTube! (Minor 6th at 0:11)

Major 6th Ascending — My Bonnie Lies Over the Ocean

Listen to the traditional My Bonnie Lies Over the Ocean on YouTube! (Major 6th at 0:24)

Major 6th Descending — Nobody Knows the Trouble I’ve Seen

Listen to the traditional Nobody Knows the Trouble I’ve Seen on YouTube! (Major 6th at 0:15)

Minor 7th Ascending — Star Trek Original Theme

Listen to Alexander Courage’s Star Trek theme on YouTube (Minor 7th at 0:30)

Minor 7th Descending — Watermelon Man

Major 7th Ascending — Take On Me

Listen to a-ha’s Take On Me on YouTube! (Major 7th at 0:54)

Major 7th Descending — I Love You

Listen to Cole Porter’s I Love You on YouTube! (Major 7th at 0:15)

Perfect Octave Ascending — Somewhere Over the Rainbow

Listen to Harold Arlen’s Somewhere Over the Rainbow on YouTube!

Perfect Octave Descending — Mozart Symphony No. 29

Listen to Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart’s Symphony No. 29 in A Major on YouTube!

Looking for a hands-on approach to intervals?

Piano students learning intervals by ear!

For ideas on how to teach intervals, remember to check out the companion post, Ear training Interval Dash, off-the-bench teaching strategy [Printables]!


Don’t miss a post!

Follow my blog (click here)! Get instant notifications of my posts in your inbox!

I appreciate shares, comments and likes. Happy teaching! <3

Rebekah Maxner, composer, blogger, piano teacher. Follow my blog for great tips!

Video of the Week

The Hanging Tree (Late Intermediate, Level 6), has a haunting quality of a lost father’s voice and bird echoes in a forest. From the print and eBook Madge’s Notebook, A Piano Tribute to The Hunger Games, Early Intermediate to Early Advanced piano, music that is a bright light in a dark world. Or, check out The Hanging Tree eSheet!

Listen to The Hanging Tree on YouTube!

Read More

Leopold Mozart’s guide on how to teach composition to creative kids

Perhaps the world’s best-known wunderkind (wonder child) of all time is the young Wolfgang Mozart. It is believed that Mozart began composing his first little keyboard pieces at the age of five. His first playful creations can be found in the Notenbuch für Nannerl, his older sister’s notebook. This notebook leaves a trail showing the young Mozart’s progress from his very first attempt at composing, to pieces that showed the results of some lessons in composition from his father, Leopold Mozart.

Wolfgang has become a bit of a legend and it’s not easy to know what to believe about his childhood musical abilities. In the beginning he truly was a very curious, alert and talented child. But he was still a beginner on the keyboard and a beginner at composing. So, what can we learn about his father’s method of teaching from Mozart’s first compositions?

It’s okay to write the music down for the child

Are you worried that if you write a child’s composition down for them, that others will question whether it’s truly their work?

Mozart’s first 14 compositions are in his father’s handwriting. Mozart composed them between the the ages of five and seven (1761 to 1763). It wasn’t until 1764, when Mozart was eight years old, that his own handwriting appears in the Notenbuch. It’s believed that his own Allegro in C, K. 5a. is the first piece he added to the book, himself.

To be clear, the young Mozart actually created these pieces on his own through improvisation. His father was simply his scribe.

It’s okay for the first pieces to be short

Mozart’s very first composition, Andante in C, K. 1a, was only 10 measures long. There was no formal structure. It was short, sweet, presented a cute musical idea or two — then suddenly stopped.

Leopold Mozart deserves credit for having written down young Wolfgang’s first piece with believable accuracy. He might have been tempted to “over teach” and ask Wolfgang to do more with the ideas, to round it out with a returning section or repeats. But he didn’t. He simply wrote the music down as Wolfgang created it — straight up. Then they moved on.

It’s okay to leave the irregularities in

Mozart’s first pieces bear the true marks of a child composer. The music is unrestrained and spontaneous. Upon listening to recordings, it’s clear that these pieces welled up out of a joyful sense of creativity.

The Andante in C, K. 1a (Mozart’s first piece) begins in 3/4 time with four measures in a decidedly Classical style, then switches to 2/4 with four measures imitating Baroque music. Two distinct styles were thus mixed into one piece, and to Leopold Mozart, that was okay.

Mozart’s next composition, Allegro in C, K. 1b, is only 12 measures long. The interplay between the right and left hand lines gives it a contrapuntal texture found in Baroque music. But instead of the final cadence occurring at the end, it arrives in an odd place between measures 8 and 9, followed by an extended Classical-sounding ending on broken C triads (chords) for the remainder of the piece. The ending hearkens to the elongated endings Wolfgang would write as an adult for opera arias and symphony movements. He already sounded like the “Mozart” we know in his second composition ever.

Leopold didn’t attempt to “correct” these stylistic mismatches in the compositions. He simply wrote them down.

YouTube video of Mozart’s earliest compositions performed on harpsichord.

It’s best to date all work

One of the sweetest things about doing research on Wolfgang Mozart’s first compositions is reading the little notes his father made in the Notenbuch of hand-written music. Leopold wrote details like, “di Wolfgango Mozart d. 11ten Maÿ 1762” and “di Wolfgango Mozart d. 30ten Novbr. 1763 à Paris“. These notes give a little window into the times, spaces and days in the life of a little boy and his dad in the middle of making music together.

When teaching a child composer, be sure to date all work. It’s a dear detail not to be missed.

It’s okay to upcycle your work

In the Notenbuch für Nannerl there’s a string of keyboard pieces composed by Wolfgang in 1763 (when he was age 7). From their genesis on the keyboard, these pieces were later upcycled to other instrumental combinations.

Violin Sonata No. 1 in C, K. 6, originated first as individual keyboard pieces that were first written down by Leopold. Then, Leopold helped to collect them together into a multi-movement work and transcribe them for violin and keyboard.

The lesson from Leopold is that composers do create their music by playing around, experimenting and developing ideas on the keyboard. Then, once it exists, this music can be transferred to any voice or instrument, or combination of instruments. Mozart wasn’t learning how to compose in his head, he was learning how to compose on the keyboard (more on this must be left for another post).

Mozart’s Opus 1, Violin Sonata No. 1 in C. K. 6.

It’s okay to give a little extra help

To continue with Violin Sonata No. 1 in C, it was published together with Sonata No. 2 as Mozart’s Opus 1 in February 1764 when he was only eight years of age.

Let’s think of Wolfgang Mozart’s first violin sonatas as a large-scale science fair project for school. Leopold is the parent in the classroom who lends his child the full capacity of his own professional expertise. His child then brings in a project well beyond the capabilities of any of his classmates, and even beyond his own abilities. Mozart’s first violin sonatas were published in Paris in the middle of the Mozarts’ first tour around Europe, and Leopold was savvy enough in business to know that his child would look even more incredible with these works in print, which in turn would increase their concert attendance and revenue.

However cynical it might seem to say that Wolfgang Mozart, himself, wasn’t quite ready to be arranging his smaller keyboard pieces into complete violin and keyboard works at the age of 7 (when compared to other work he was producing at the time), I’m actually pointing out how Leopold went about developing a world-class composer. Leopold proved that it’s actually okay to be the parent in the classroom helping your kid excel at their project.

What does it say about the parent who is helping their child? They’re involved. They’re present with their child. They’re invested in their child’s success. The whole time they’re doing their kid’s project with them, this parent is teaching their child many valuable lessons that will in fact increase their child’s knowledge, abilities and skillset.

In Wolfgang’s case, it worked. He absorbed everything musical his father showed him. Except…Wolfgang didn’t quite pay enough attention to Leopold’s business smarts or lessons in finance.

It’s okay to let details slide

If you’ve ever seen the movie Amadeus, the catchy little piece played by the child Mozart on the palace harpsichord is his own Klavierstück in F (Keyboard Piece in F), K. 33B. Mozart composed it in October 1766, just as his family’s three-and-a-half year European tour was coming to an end. He was nine at the time. (In the movie, Mozart is portrayed by a much younger actor.) It was written in pencil on the reverse side of a pamphlet advertising two upcoming concerts that were to be performed by Wolfgang and his sister, Nannerl, on October 7th and 9th.

By this time, young Mozart understood a little on how to structure a piece of music. Like many Baroque and Galant pieces (Galant referring to the transitional period from 1720 to 1770 when there was a return to simplicity in music), the Klavierstück in F is in two sections with repeats. But unlike the majority of such pieces, it’s not in true binary form, as the first section finishes not in the dominant, but lands back in the home key of F. This detail means that it’s still an example of a child’s piece, composed simply the way Wolfgang dreamed it up and not according to the harmonic rules that fully trained composers followed at the time.

As with Mozart’s very earliest compositions, Leopold left this detail untouched and didn’t “fix” it — he let his child’s music just stay the way it was. Mozart was still a child composer, writing child-like music.

Scene from the Movie Amadeus in which the child Mozart plays his Klavierstück in F.

It’s best to put the child’s own name on the pieces

There is a piece of music in the Notebook for Mozart that has traditionally been attributed to his father, Leopold: Burlesque. But based on the details within the music itself, it may be possible to prove that Burlesque was not composed by his father, but by the child Mozart. Let me explain.

[Aside: A twentieth-century music historian has cast doubt on the origins of this book, theorizing that it is a forgery based on the inscription in the front cover. But let’s put that aside for the moment, and stay on topic. Let’s believe that this book is indeed from the Mozart family.]

Every composer embeds a unique handprint within their music. A composer will sit at the piano (or harpsichord), and through the music they’ve learned and through muscle memory, they will improvise. And as they improvise, certain learned or familiar muscle patterns will emerge over several compositions. It is what gives each composer their own recognizable, distinct style.

Burlesque contains patterns that are consistent with Klavierstück in F (mentioned above), which is a confirmed composition by the child Mozart. You don’t even need to know how to read music to notice the similarity in the patterns in the left hand parts between Klavierstück in F and Burlesque. Both have broken octaves, and in both the left hand pattern even jumps from the tonic to mediant.

Sheet music titled 'Klavierstück in F (Keyboard Piece in F) K. 33B' by W. A. Mozart, with musical notations and annotations.

You may wonder whether the child Mozart was able to compose the Klavierstück because he had already learned Burlesque, and that’s why there’s a similarity between the two pieces. What if the father Mozart had composed the Burlesque and because Mozart had played it, his muscles were able to create the Klavierstück?

Beyond the similarity between the lower voices, there’s another feature in Burlesque’s B section that leads me to believe it must have been composed by a child: the irregular phrase lengths. In the Classical period, a time when music was orderly, neat, tidy, organized and graceful, no grown, trained composer would have written two-and-a-half measure phrases. Simply put, these phrases are off-kilter in a way that was rarely (if ever) seen at that time in music history. I believe they’re there because all child composers (apparently including Mozart) have interesting timing anomalies in their music. Kudos to Leopold for leaving them there.

What’s more, there’s a chance that the child Mozart based Burlesque on various versions of Twinkle (which in his day went by various names across Europe). In short, this Burlesque is Twinkle, Twinkle Little Star, with some added notes and missing beats. If you haven’t yet read my blog series on Twinkle, Twinkle Little Star, I’d encourage you to do so, because the child Mozart likely heard it in its various guises across the European continent in his travels. It left an indelible mark on him.

The more I think about it, the more I believe that we need to reconsider who the composer of Burlesque was. I believe it was the child Mozart, himself. This confusion could have been avoided if his own name had been written on the original manuscript. It’s a lesson to us all to date and name the composer on each piece.

It takes teamwork to make a child composer

If you are a music teacher teaching composition to children, take Leopold’s lessons to heart. Be the young composer’s teammate.

At first, just allow your students to compose what they want to. Accept their music precisely the way they present it to you. Let them create it at the instrument. Write it down for them. (This isn’t cheating, it’s teaching.)

Don’t fix the little kid-like idiosyncrasies that creep in. Nitpicking might make your student shy away from trying to compose again. Is your student’s piece without form? Let it stay that way. Later, show your student how music is put together with the pieces they are learning to play. This may influence their next compositions.

As you teach more complex composition techniques, be generous in your help if the student wants or needs it. They’ll see you in action and learn how it’s done.

Preparing students for a composition contest? This is the time to let them do it on their own. Sometimes talented kids have a difficult time writing down their own music. Their inventiveness and ability to create music exceeds their understanding of notation. Yet contests require music to be written in the child’s own handwriting. Try writing it yourself and let them copy it over. Do this until they’re ready to begin writing down their own music.

Leopold Mozart is a very inspiring example of just how well it can go if a young child is given the freedom to create on his or her own terms and offered a guiding hand!

Appendix of Mozart’s early compositions

All of Wolfgang Mozart’s early compositions in the Notenbuch für Nannerl are for keyboard. It is believed that only four of them are in his own handwriting. He presumably added these in 1764 when he was eight years of age (one year before the Klavierstück in F, K. 33B mentioned above).

This is assembled roughly in chronological order, according to musicologists. If you’d like to see the same information organized in the order in which it appears in the Notebook, see Wikipedia.

CompositionCatalogueCopyistNotenbuch contents entry, Dates, Notes
Andante in CK. 1aLeopold53; possibly first composition, age 5
Allegro in CK. 1bLeopold54; possibly written in 1761, age 5
Allegro in FK. 1cLeopold55; possibly written in 1761, age 5
Menuett in FK. 1dLeopold56; minuet by Wolfgang Mozart on 16 December 1761, age 5
Menuett in FK. 2Leopold58; Leopold likely copyist, (age 6?)
Allegro in B-flatK. 3Leopold59; by Wolfgang Mozart on 4 March 1762, in Salzburg, age 6
Menuett in FK. 4Leopold49; by Wolfgang Mozart on 11 May 1762, in Salzburg, age 6
Menuett in FK. 5Leopold61; 5 July 1762, in Salzburg, Leopold likely copyist, age 6
Menuett in FK. 6Leopold48; by Wolfgang Mozart 16 July 1762, in Salzburg, age 6; A piano version of the third movement of Leopold’s Serenade in D and Menuet II from the third movement of Wolfgang’s Violin Sonata No. 1 in C
Allegro in CK. 6Leopold46; by Wolfgang 14 October; possibly composed in Brussels 1763, age 7; A piano version of the first movement of Violin Sonata No. 1
Andante in FK. 6Leopold25; probably composed in Brussels 1763, age 7; A piano version of the second movement of Violin Sonata No. 1 in C
Menuett in CK. 6Leopold26; probably composed in Brussels 1763, age 7; A piano version of Menuet I from the third movement of Violin Sonata No. 1 in C
Menuett in DK. 7Leopold47; by Wolfgang Mozart 30 November 1763, age 7; A piano version of Menuet I from Violin Sonata No. 2 in D
Allegro in B-flatK. 8Leopold24; by Wolfgang Mozart in Paris on 21 November 1763, age 7; A piano version of the first movement of Violin Sonata No. 3 in B-flat
Allegro in CK. 5aWolfgang20; probably added in 1764, age 8
Menuett in GK. 1eWolfgang62; probably added in 1764, age 8
Menuett in CK. 1fWolfgang63; probably added in 1764, age 8
Andante in B-flatK. 5bWolfgang64; fragment, probably added in 1764, age 8

Don’t miss a post!

Follow my blog (click here)! Get instant notifications of my posts in your inbox!

I appreciate shares, comments and likes. Happy teaching! <3

Rebekah Maxner, composer, blogger, piano teacher. Follow my blog for great tips!

Video of the Week

Misty River (Late Elementary, Level 2), a finely-woven, spinning soundscape that can carry you away on imagination. From the print and eBook Rock That Train, Elementary to Late Elementary piano solos. Or, check out the Misty River eSheet!

Listen to Misty River on YouTube!
Here’s a sound clip of Misty River!

Read More

Finger numbers for piano students at home! [FREE printable!]

Let’s explore finger numbers!

For piano parents

My name is Rebekah Maxner and your teacher is a follower of my Piano at Play blog. As a perk, here’s a learning tool I’ve developed to help you and your child with piano finger numbers at home!

Prep 1

Print this FREE black and white worksheet.

Prep 2

Have five coloured pencils ready:

  • Blue
  • Green
  • Yellow
  • Orange and
  • Red

For piano students

Step 1

Connect fingers that have matching numbers with coloured arches. Follow the order suggested below and on the sheet.

  • Find both thumbs. What’s the matching number? Connect them with BLUE.
  • Find both pointer fingers. What’s the matching number? Connect them with GREEN.
  • Find both tall man fingers. What’s the matching number? Connect them with YELLOW.
  • Find both ring man fingers. What’s the matching number? Connect them with ORANGE.
  • Find both pinky fingers. What’s the matching number? Connect them with RED.

Watch this video to set up your page!

STEP 1: This video helps you make your finger number rainbow!

What do you see? A Finger Number Rainbow!

Step 2

Let’s sing the finger numbers!

Place your page in front of you. If you can, kneel on the floor with your knees in front.

Practice singing with this video at home. It’s a sing-along song! Sing it to the tune of Frère Jacques, with actions.

1

Where is thumbkin?
Where is thumbkin?
Hold hands in a loose fist.
Here I am,
Number One!
Hold hands loose and open, wiggle both thumbs to the beat.
Show me how you play, One,
Show me how you play, One!
Touch thumb tips together to the beat.
On my knees,
On my knees!
Play thumbs on knees as you would on piano keys to the beat.

2

Where is pointer?
Where is pointer?
Hold hands in a loose fist.
Here I am,
Number Two!
Hold hands loose and open, wiggle both pointers to the beat.
Show me how you play, Two,
Show me how you play, Two!
Touch pointer fingertips together to the beat.
On my knees,
On my knees!
Play pointers on knees as you would on piano keys to the beat.

3

Where is tall man?
Where is tall man?
Hold hands in a loose fist.
Here I am,
Number Three!
Hold hands loose and open, wiggle both tall man fingers to the beat.
Show me how you play, Three, Show me how you play, Three!Touch tall man fingertips together to the beat.
On my knees,
On my knees!
Play tall man fingers on knees as you would on piano keys to the beat.

4

Where is ring man?
Where is ring man?
Hold hands in a loose fist.
Here I am,
Number Four!
Hold hands loose and open, wiggle both ring man fingers to the beat.
Show me how you play, Four, Show me how you play, Four!Touch ring man fingertips together to the beat.
On my knees,
On my knees!
Play ring man fingers on knees as you would on piano keys to the beat.

5

Where is pinky?
Where is pinky?
Hold hands in a loose fist.
Here I am,
Number Five!
Hold hands loose and open, wiggle both pinkies to the beat.
Show me how you play, Five,
Show me how you play, Five!
Touch pinky fingertips together to the beat.
On my knees,
On my knees!
Play pinkies on knees as you would on piano keys to the beat.

Copyright notice. Finger Number Rainbow concept and design, song and words Copyright (c) 2003 by Rebekah Maxner. All rights reserved. Teachers may use the reproducible sheet provided by Piano at Play blog with personal students. Piano method writers and/or publishers may not publish or reproduce this design or concept.

Learning that the numbers are mirrored is the key to avoiding confusion and encouraging confidence from day one!

For teachers

Please share this blog post with your piano families! As my appreciation for reading my blog, it’s free!

My blog content helps make your teaching easier! But did you know I’m a composer? Purchasing and teaching my music helps me continue to provide this content for FREE! Check out my shop!

Many thanks!


Don’t miss a post!

Follow my blog (click here)! Get instant notifications of my posts in your inbox!

I appreciate shares, comments and likes. Happy teaching! ❤

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is bio-photo.jpg
Rebekah Maxner, composer, blogger, piano teacher. Follow my blog for great tips!

Video of the Week

Skitter Scatter, Pitter Patter (Early Elementary, Prep A), an early reading piece that encourages confidence reading the middle of the staff that’s really fun to play! From the print and eBook Rock the Boat, 11 Early Elementary piano works with optional teacher duets. Or, Check out the studio-licensed Skitter Scatter, Pitter Patter eSheet!

Read More

Piano finger numbers! Teach and review with beginners [Online or in person]

Do your young piano students ever mix up their finger numbers?

Sometimes kids think their left hand pinky is finger 1, because they mix it up with the order of the right hand finger numbers.

And do kids always remember which finger is 2 and which is 4 (either hand)?

Unless finger numbers are taught very carefully in the beginning, this reversal of finger numbers can keep happening long into the piano lesson journey.

When students mix up little things like finger numbers it’s really difficult to get on with real music-making. And sometimes their finger number insecurity can haunt them for years!

The trouble with how finger numbers are taught

All standard piano methods have a page or two on finger numbers. There are three common approaches:

  1. There’s a writing activity in which the student fills in the finger numbers on a picture of two hands.
  2. The student is asked to wiggle fingers as the teacher calls them out.
  3. Usually the student is asked to wiggle only one finger at a time, right hand or left hand.

While the child might be able to write the numbers correctly on a picture, there’s very little visual direction to instil that the finger numbers are mirrored.

Wiggling fingers is not very helpful in instilling the numbers in students. It’s simply not tactile enough. (Besides, wiggling isn’t a motion used in actual piano playing.)

Also, when the finger numbers are practiced only one hand at a time, there’s a disconnect between the hands and which fingers have matching numbers.

That’s why students get confused.

But what if you could teach finger numbers in three integrated and unforgettable ways to ensure that your students know them for sure — from day one?

How to teach finger numbers so students will remember

I’m willing to share with you the special approach I developed for my students and have been using for over 20 years. My students have enjoyed remarkable success!

It’s Visual

In one simple image, the rainbow highlights the matching finger numbers.

Learning that the numbers are mirrored is the key to avoiding confusion and encouraging confidence from day one!

It’s Auditory (learning by sound)

The song that accompanies the rainbow teaches the finger numbers through words and music, and reinforces which fingers have matching numbers.

There’s a music video students and parents can sing along with at home!

Singing songs helps us encode information. The song’s lyrics help us store and retrieve the knowledge we need to remember. It’s science.

It’s Kinesthetic (learning through touch)

The actions of the song instil by feel which fingers have matching numbers.

The physicality of singing the song helps with remembering the actual numbers, themselves.

The Rainbow finger number strategy includes actions that reinforce matching fingers.

The actions to the song add a tactile dimension to the learning process. This activates both hemispheres of the brain and creates deep memory pathways for the child.

Two of the actions are for matching fingertips, emulating the feeling of playing the piano keys and reinforcing the mirrored numbers.

Use this teaching strategy with your beginners and you’ll notice them learning and remembering their finger numbers with greater success!

Copyright notice. Finger Number Rainbow concept and design, song and words Copyright (c) 2003 by Rebekah Maxner. All rights reserved. Teachers may use the reproducible sheet provided by Piano at Play blog with personal students. Piano method writers and/or publishers may not publish or reproduce this design or concept.

Want to use this approach with your students for FREE?

I’ve created a special blog post for beginner piano students and their parents to use at home, and I’m sharing the link so you can use it, too!

Go to the link:

  • To see how the Rainbow Finger Numbers teaching strategy really works
  • To watch the videos
  • To get the reproducible printable

Whether you’re teaching in person or online, share my student-friendly post directly with your piano families! Click the following link:

Finger numbers for piano students at home!

For teachers

My blog content helps make your teaching easier! But did you know I’m a composer? Purchasing and teaching my music helps me continue to provide this content for FREE! Check out my shop for music your students will love to play!


Don’t miss a post!

Follow my blog (click here)! Get instant notifications of my posts in your inbox!

I appreciate shares, comments and likes. Happy teaching! ❤

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is bio-photo.jpg
Rebekah Maxner, composer, blogger, piano teacher. Follow my blog for great tips!

Video of the Week

Scat, Cat! (Early Elementary, Prep A), a mini toccata and fugue! This piece begins with a toccata-like intro, then has imitation between student and teacher (like a fugue). From the print and eBook Rock the Boat, 11 Early Elementary piano works with optional teacher duets. Or, Check out the studio-licensed Scat, Cat! eSheet!

YouTube video of “Scat Cat!”

Read More

Shopping cart

0
image/svg+xml

No products in the cart.

Continue Shopping